Research · Four-arm workflow · Diagram D · Slide 11

Arm D: the start-over rebuild, left incomplete

Every arm answers the same three questions. What do I ask next? When do I stop? What may I say? Arm D kept B's honesty about words — no numbers ever — but tied refusal to a count that never reached zero.

Arm D: the start-over rebuild, left incomplete Arm D is a start-over rebuild with reportables bolted onto every list. It asks the shared unknown sign. It never opens the vet door, so the whole ranked list is named out loud. while a sign is still worth asking and an allowed answer remains. 1 HEAR Observations arrive as facts. Model may only help with text. 2 BUILD THE LIST ASF, CSF, FMD stay on the list every time. Others join on match. Order by counts only. ASF CSF FMD 3 CHOOSE WHAT TO ASK Unknown, unasked sign the most listed diseases declare. Not what splits them. 4 ASK One question per message. Question limit: 4 allowed answers, plus up to 2 extra answers. 5 DECIDE WHETHER TO STOP Send to the veterinarian only when list empty or supporting-sign count is zero. Door stays shut. 6 DECIDE WHAT MAY BE SAID Safety check reviews the draft answer. Then the ranked list goes to the Farm Operator. 7 SAY Name the top disease or the tie. Show the whole list. Checked ones named out loud. 8 RECORD Keep the event record. No reason is stored for a question that was not asked. 9 REFUSAL / VET DOOR NOT REACHED Present in the code. Example: on a weaned-piglet diarrhoea Health Event, question four asked about sow abortion — PRRS still stayed on the list. METAPHOR ASF CSF FMD SHUT SAY NEVER EMPTY SEALED 8-CASE PACK · D acc 6/8 beside A 4/8 · D sends 0 beside A 2 · D wrongly named reportable 5/8 beside A 0/8 LEGEND Stage Alarm / no source given Refusal door Record Main flow Loop / write Reportables stay on the list

Full sentences · matched to the numbered chips

  1. 1

    HEAR

    The Farm Operator's observations arrive as facts. The model may only help with text.

  2. 2

    BUILD THE LIST

    The three reportable diseases — ASF, CSF, FMD — are put on the list every time. This happens whatever the signs say. Other diseases join only when the pattern matches. For each disease, count supporting, contradicting and missing signs. Order by counts alone. No probability anywhere.

  3. 3

    CHOOSE WHAT TO ASK

    Ask about the unknown, unasked sign that the most diseases still on the list declare. Not what splits them — what they share.

  4. 4

    ASK

    One question per message. Question limit: 4 allowed answers, plus up to 2 extra answers.

  5. 5

    DECIDE WHETHER TO STOP

    Send to the veterinarian only when the list is empty or the top disease has zero supporting signs. In the 8 measured Health Events, neither ever happened. The list always held the three reportables. The top disease's supporting-sign count never fell to zero. So the door never opened — 0 sends to the veterinarian in 8 rows.

    SEALED 8-CASE PACK: D sends to the veterinarian 0 beside A 2.

  6. 6

    DECIDE WHAT MAY BE SAID

    A safety check reviews the draft answer. Then it lets the whole ranked list go out as the Farm Operator's list of possible diseases.

  7. 7

    SAY

    Name the top disease or the tie. Show that whole list. So reportables that were only meant to be checked get named out loud.

  8. 8

    RECORD

    Keep the event record. No reason is stored for a question that was not asked.

  9. 9

    REFUSAL / VET DOOR

    Present in the code, not reached on the measured path.

Caption

A start-over rebuild, left incomplete

The rebuild kept B's honesty about words — no numbers ever — but tied refusal to a count that never reached zero. SEALED 8-CASE PACK: D wrongly named reportable 5/8 beside A 0/8. A reportable reaches the Farm Operator's list of possible diseases on ordinary or out-of-catalogue cases. SEALED 8-CASE PACK: D sends to the veterinarian 0 beside A 2. Reportables always stay on the list, so the ranked set is never empty and the refusal condition is never reached. Nothing is deployed.

Changed from

C3 — a start-over rebuild

Changed from C3: it keeps only the shared nine-stage frame and B's honesty about words. This is a start-over rebuild, not a C3 one-step change. It adds reportables that stay on the list every time. It asks what most diseases share. Stop is never reached, so the door stays shut. The ranked list is named out loud to the Farm Operator.

How to read

Marks on this drawing

  • Red: reportables stay on the list every time; the door never opened; the whole list is said
  • Grey padlock: the door is present in the code, not reached on the measured path
  • Slot: bolted reportables jam the padlocked door; one stays on the list and goes along the ranked-list arrow toward SAY
  • Loop: keep asking while a sign is still worth asking and an allowed answer remains